[JP] "High-Speed Stalemate: Rethinking Blame, Risk, and Viability in Japan’s Chūō Shinkansen Maglev Project"

[Eurorapid]

-
The Chūō Shinkansen Maglev Project: Delays, Environmental Concerns, and the Political Economy of Blame


The Chūō Shinkansen maglev, planned to connect Tokyo and Osaka, has faced substantial delays and environmental controversies. While public discourse has frequently attributed setbacks to opposition from Shizuoka Prefecture—particularly under Governor Heita Kawakatsu—construction delays have occurred in all prefectures along the route. Analysis of project timelines indicates that the originally announced 2027 opening was infeasible from inception.

Central Japan Railway Company (JR Tōkai) publicly acknowledged the postponement only in March 2024, after years of framing Shizuoka as the primary obstacle. This narrative, amplified by national media, deflected scrutiny from unresolved construction issues elsewhere. Nearly twenty sections outside Shizuoka remain uninitiated, and certain active segments—such as the Yamanashi-side portion of the Southern Alps Tunnel—may not be completed until the mid-2040s.

Nationwide, the project has generated significant environmental impacts, including spring water depletion and land subsidence in Mizunami City (Gifu Prefecture), and oxygen-deficient air emissions in Machida City (Tokyo). Less-publicized problems include chronic noise pollution along the Yamanashi maglev test line, forced relocations, water shortages, and improper spoil disposal. Multiple civil actions seeking to halt construction are ongoing.

Media coverage has been uneven, in part due to JR Tōkai’s status as a major advertiser and the scarcity of journalists assigned to long-term infrastructure oversight. Public opinion, once strongly favorable, is shifting toward environmental prioritization and skepticism regarding necessity.

Economic viability is also in question. In 2013, JR Tōkai’s then-president publicly stated that the maglev “would never pay for itself,” a view reportedly shared by the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism. Current fare projections—¥700–¥1,000 above Nozomi Shinkansen prices—are unlikely to achieve profitability. International parallels reinforce concerns: projected fares for JR Tōkai’s proposed Washington–Baltimore maglev would be up to eight times higher than conventional rail, affordable to only the wealthiest two percent of potential passengers.

Full operational utility depends on completing the Tokyo–Osaka corridor; however, projections suggest Osaka service may not commence until the 2060s. Without this extension, ridership growth on the initial Shinagawa–Nagoya segment will likely remain limited.

The Chūō Shinkansen represents both an engineering milestone and a national prestige project. Yet it is equally a case study in environmental risk, political framing, and the structural vulnerabilities of media–infrastructure relations. Given the irreversibility of certain ecological impacts, a reassessment of project governance, transparency, and necessity is warranted before further commitments are made.

Info and statements based on translated texts from https://shueisha.online/articles/-/2547 ... ing&page=1 Accessed 2025-08-08